The CW told officers that the defendant showed her child
pornography on his iPad, naked images of young girls, approximately seven or
eight years old. In addition, the CW stated that Theil admitted to her that he
had previously sexually abused his niece on multiple occasions when she was
approximately 14 years old.
The CW further stated that on another occasion, Theil asked
her to facilitate a sexual encounter with a minor female. The CW arranged for
an 18-year-old friend, who looked much younger, to meet with Theil in a hotel
room in Ithaca, NY. The defendant paid the CW $1,200 for the session with the
alleged 14-year-old. After the session, Theil contacted the CW and asked that
she find a true minor female. In hopes of getting money, the CW fabricated a
story that she babysat two sisters, ages eight and 12, and that she could
facilitate the defendant having a session with the 12-year-old. The CW told
officers she had no intention of providing a minor female because she found it
inappropriate but hoped to steal money from Theil when he showed up
anticipating the session.
On December 15, 2016, search warrants were executed at the
defendant’s residence in Corning, NY and at Theil’s lake house in Hammondsport,
NY. Following the searches, a forensic examination of the defendant’s computer
revealed 367 images of child pornography on Theil’s laptop.
The defendant made an initial appearance before U.S.
Magistrate Judge John W. Feldman and was released.
The complaint is the result of an investigation by the
Federal Bureau of Investigation, under the direction of Special Agent-in-Charge
Adam S. Cohen, the New York State Police, under the direction of Major Richard
Allen, and the Steuben County Sheriff’s Department, under the direction of
Sheriff James Allard.